MarketMYSTR Email: The Complete Setup Guide

MarketMYSTR gives you two ways to send email: the built-in MarketMYSTR Email service (recommended for most users) or your own SMTP provider. This guide covers both, plus domain authentication, reply routing, and when to consider a dedicated IP.

What is MarketMYSTR Email?

MarketMYSTR Email is the built-in email-sending engine that powers your account. You don't need to separately sign up for Mailgun, SendGrid, or any other third-party service — sending and receiving just works with minimal setup, once you authenticate your domain.

It's built on a reputation-managed infrastructure with industry-leading deliverability, error monitoring, and compliance — and it's considerably cheaper than running your own third-party SMTP.

For most STR businesses, MarketMYSTR Email is the right choice. It's cheaper than external SMTP, pre-configured for deliverability, and works out of the box once your domain is authenticated. You only need to switch to SMTP in specific cases (existing provider relationships, very specific compliance requirements, or advanced use cases).

Pricing

MarketMYSTR Email pricing is usage-based, charged at the agency level:

Service Rate
MarketMYSTR Email sending $0.675 per 1,000 emails
Email verification (optional, validates addresses before send) $2.50 per 1,000 verifications
Email forwarding (when enabled) Same as MarketMYSTR Email rate ($0.675 per 1,000)
Dedicated IP (optional) $59 per month per IP

Both outgoing and incoming emails are billed — including To, CC, and BCC recipients. Forwarded emails are billed the same as regular outbound emails.

Sending limits & the ramp-up model

New sub-accounts don't get full sending power on day one. MarketMYSTR uses a gradual ramp-up model that builds your sending reputation over the first week to avoid spam filters.

Day Daily email limit
Day 1250
Day 2500
Day 31,000
Day 42,500
Day 55,000
Day 67,500
Day 710,000
Day 8 and onwards (shared domain)150,000
Day 8 and onwards (dedicated domain + IP)450,000

The daily counter resets at 00:00:01 UTC. If you hit the limit before the reset, sending pauses until the next day.

Sub-accounts without a dedicated domain are capped at 15,000/day — even if the parent agency has a dedicated domain. To unlock the 450,000/day ceiling, the sub-account itself needs a dedicated sending domain. See the Dedicated IP section for when to consider this.

MarketMYSTR Email vs SMTP — which should you use?

Factor MarketMYSTR Email Your own SMTP (Mailgun, SendGrid, etc.)
Setup time 15 minutes (add DNS records) 30–60 minutes (separate account + API key + DNS)
Cost $0.675 per 1,000 emails Varies by provider; usually higher
Deliverability Managed reputation — high by default Depends on provider and volume
Stats Delivered, opened, clicked, bounced Opened and clicked only (most SMTP providers)
Reply tracking into Conversations Yes Limited; forwarding only works with Mailgun
HIPAA compliant Yes (with HIPAA package) Depends on provider
Best for Most STR hosts and CoHosts Enterprises with existing provider relationships
SMTP is considered an advanced use case. If you're just starting out, stick with MarketMYSTR Email. SMTP support is provided on a best-effort basis — it's designed for experienced users with specific requirements, not the default path.

Domain authentication — SPF, DKIM, DMARC

These three DNS records are what make email actually work. Without them, your emails will land in spam folders — or be rejected entirely by major inbox providers.

SPF (Sender Policy Framework)

Declares which mail servers are authorized to send emails on behalf of your domain. Without SPF, receiving servers can't verify the sender is legitimate.

DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail)

Adds a cryptographic signature to every email. The receiving server verifies the signature against a public key published in your DNS — proving the email wasn't tampered with and really came from an authorized sender.

DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication)

Tells receiving servers what to do if a message fails SPF or DKIM checks. A basic DMARC record says "my domain uses SPF and DKIM — be suspicious of anything that doesn't pass."

Only one SPF record and one DMARC record per domain. If you already have an SPF record (e.g., from Google Workspace), you need to merge MarketMYSTR's SPF values into the existing record — don't create a second one. Multiple SPF records break authentication entirely.

Setting up MarketMYSTR Email — step by step

Setup happens under Settings → Email Services. For dedicated domain setup: Settings → Email Services → Dedicated Domain & IP.

  1. Go to Email Services Navigate to Settings → Email Services → Dedicated Domain & IP in your MarketMYSTR account. Click + Add Domain in the top right.
  2. Enter your sending domain We recommend using a subdomain like mail.yourdomain.com rather than your root domain. This protects your root domain's reputation and keeps email authentication isolated. Click Add & Verify.
  3. Copy the DNS records MarketMYSTR will display the DNS records you need to add (SPF, DKIM, DMARC, and sometimes CNAME or MX). Each has a Copy button next to it — handy for pasting into your domain host.
  4. Add the records at your domain host Log in to your domain host (GoDaddy, Namecheap, Cloudflare, etc.) and add each record exactly as MarketMYSTR showed you. Set TTL to 5 minutes (300 seconds) where possible — this makes future changes propagate faster. See our DNS guide for step-by-step instructions per provider.
  5. Verify Return to MarketMYSTR. Click the three-dot menu next to your domain and select Verify Domain. The system will check each record in real time. DNS propagation typically takes 1–10 minutes but can occasionally stretch up to 24–48 hours.
  6. SSL provisioning Once verification passes, SSL is automatically provisioned for your domain — usually within 1–10 minutes. Your sending domain is then fully live.
  7. Send a test email Send a test to yourself. Check headers to confirm SPF and DKIM show as "Pass." Check that the email doesn't land in spam.
For supported DNS providers, you can skip the manual step. If your domain is at GoDaddy, Google Domains, or Cloudflare, MarketMYSTR offers an Auto-Configure option. You authorize MarketMYSTR to connect to your DNS directly, and the records are added automatically. See the Connecting your domain guide for details.

Using your own SMTP instead

If you need to use an external SMTP provider, MarketMYSTR supports most major ones. Setup happens under Settings → Email Services → SMTP.

You'll need from your SMTP provider:

Provider-specific notes

SendGrid

Create an API key at Settings → API Keys → Create API Key. Use apikey as the username and the API key as the password in MarketMYSTR.

Mailgun

After adding and verifying your domain in Mailgun, create an SMTP credential at Sending → Domain Settings → SMTP Credentials. Of the external SMTP providers, Mailgun has the deepest integration with MarketMYSTR — it's the only provider besides MarketMYSTR Email where features like Forwarding Address and BCC work.

Zoho

Generate an app-specific password in your Zoho account (don't use your regular password). Use SMTP server smtp.zoho.com, port 587.

Amazon SES

Generate SMTP credentials in the AWS SES console. Use port 465. New SES accounts are in sandbox mode — you can only send to verified addresses until you request production access.

Free email providers won't work. Gmail (personal), Yahoo, Hotmail, and other free email services can't be used as your SMTP. Yahoo has disabled SMTP entirely. Gmail has very low daily limits when connected via SMTP (~100–150/day). If you want Gmail integration, use the 2-way sync feature instead (see below) — not SMTP.

Google & Outlook 2-way sync (not SMTP)

If you're trying to integrate Gmail / Google Workspace or Outlook / Microsoft 365, don't use SMTP — MarketMYSTR has direct 2-way sync integrations for these providers that work much better.

These integrations give you full sync (sent, received, replies, forwards) without any of the SMTP limitations.

Reply & Forward settings

When someone replies to an email you sent, where does the reply go? You configure this at Settings → Email Services → Reply & Forward Settings.

Reply Address

By default, replies land in the MarketMYSTR Conversations tab. If you'd rather route replies to specific email addresses instead, you can configure up to 5 reply addresses. Note: if you route replies to an external inbox, your reply to the lead from that inbox won't sync back into MarketMYSTR.

Forwarding Address

Replies always go to Conversations. A Forwarding Address sends a copy of each reply to an external email as well. You can enter multiple forwarding addresses separated by commas.

Forwarding and BCC only work with MarketMYSTR Email or Mailgun. If you're using an external SMTP (SendGrid, Zoho, Amazon SES, etc.), the Forwarding Address and BCC features don't function. This is one reason MarketMYSTR Email or Mailgun are preferred for most STR businesses.

Forward to Assigned User

Automatically forwards replies to whichever MarketMYSTR user is assigned to the contact. The assigned user's email is pulled from Settings → My Staff → edit User → User Info.

BCC Emails

Configure under Settings → Email Services → Reply & Forward Settings → BCC Emails. When set, you'll receive a blind carbon copy of every 1-to-1 email, workflow email, and billing email sent from that sub-account.

BCC doesn't work for bulk or campaign emails. Only 1-to-1 emails, workflow emails, and billing emails trigger the BCC. Large campaign sends (e.g., marketing blasts) are excluded.

Dedicated IP — when & why

By default, MarketMYSTR Email sends through shared IP addresses — your emails go out alongside thousands of other businesses from the same IP pool. Deliverability on shared IPs is good because the pool is actively managed.

A dedicated IP is an IP address assigned exclusively to you. Your sending reputation is yours alone — not affected by other senders.

Dedicated IP pricing

$59 per month per IP, billed at the agency level. The agency can set up rebilling to pass this cost through to sub-accounts.

When to get a dedicated IP

When you shouldn't

Eligibility

Dedicated IPs are available for agencies on specific plan tiers ($297+/month or $497+/month). The agency must have been created at least 14 days ago. Sub-accounts qualify if they have 10,000+ contacts or have sent 50,000+ emails in the last 10 days.

How to buy

  1. Navigate to Agency Settings → Email Services → Dedicated Domain & IP
  2. Click Buy IP
  3. Click Buy Now in the modal that appears
  4. The IP is provisioned immediately. Assign it to your dedicated sending domain by clicking the three-dot menu next to the domain and selecting Assign IP

IP warm-up

A brand-new IP has zero reputation. MarketMYSTR's dedicated IP setup includes automated warm-up — during this phase (2–4 weeks typically), your emails alternate in a 50/50 split between your dedicated IP and a shared IP. This gradually builds reputation on the dedicated IP without blasting a cold IP with full volume. You may see the warm-up still in progress even after considerable time; this is normal.

Send at least 50,000 messages per week on your dedicated IP to maintain a healthy reputation. One dedicated IP per 1 million messages per month is the recommended ratio.

Deliverability best practices

  1. Authenticate your domain. SPF, DKIM, DMARC — non-negotiable.
  2. Use a business domain, not a free Gmail or Yahoo address for sending. you@yourbusiness.com always beats yourbusiness@gmail.com.
  3. Clean your list. Remove hard bounces and unengaged recipients. A list with 5% bounces will hurt you; a clean list with 0.5% bounces will help you.
  4. Make unsubscribe obvious. A visible unsubscribe link at the bottom of every email is required by law (CAN-SPAM) and helps your reputation.
  5. Write like a human, not a marketer. Subject lines with ALL CAPS, "FREE!!!", and aggressive emoji spam get filtered.
  6. Send consistently. Weekly consistency beats monthly bursts for building reputation.
  7. Use email verification on large imports. Catching invalid addresses before sending keeps your bounce rate low.

Troubleshooting

"DNS records won't verify"

Wait at least 30 minutes after adding records. If still failing, use MXToolbox to check your SPF/DKIM/DMARC records are visible. Most common cause: typos when copying the DKIM record (it's long — copy the whole string, including any trailing characters). Double-check that the host/name field uses just the subdomain prefix, not the full domain.

"Emails land in spam"

Run your domain through MXToolbox Email Health and fix any warnings. Check for: incomplete authentication, sending from a Gmail/Yahoo address instead of your business domain, overly promotional content, too many capitalized words in subject lines.

"Sending quota exceeded"

You've hit your current ramp-up limit or your plan's monthly allowance. Check usage at Agency View → Billing → Credits. Either wait for the next day's reset (00:00:01 UTC), reduce your scheduled send size, or split the campaign into batches. If you've just started and hit the ramp-up wall, that resolves itself as you move through the week.

"Emails via SMTP are stuck in 'sent' status"

SMTP providers only report sent, open, and click events — not delivered. MarketMYSTR marks an email as "delivered" only after an open event is received. So a message shows "sent" until the recipient opens it. This is a fundamental SMTP limitation — switch to MarketMYSTR Email or Mailgun for full delivery tracking.

"Replies aren't coming into Conversations"

If you're using SMTP other than Mailgun, the reply-to address will show MarketMYSTR's routing address (e.g., testing@replies.subdomain.com) — replies to that address land in Conversations correctly. If you instead click the sender's email address directly to start a new email thread, those replies won't sync. Always use the system reply-to address.

FAQs

Can I migrate from an existing SMTP to MarketMYSTR Email later?

Yes. You can switch between SMTP and MarketMYSTR Email at any time under Settings → Email Services. Your existing workflows, templates, and contact history are preserved.

Where can I see my email usage?

At the agency level: Agency View → Billing → Credits. At the sub-account level: Settings → Email Services → Usage.

Can I rebill my clients for email usage?

Yes — Pro plan agencies can enable rebilling so email usage gets passed through to sub-account billing.

Is MarketMYSTR Email HIPAA compliant?

Yes — with the HIPAA compliance package (Twilio has a signed BAA for HIPAA compliance). Contact support if you need HIPAA covered for your account.

Does cold email work with MarketMYSTR Email?

Yes — with proper warm-up and list hygiene. Cold email is higher-risk than transactional sending, so use a dedicated domain and IP, warm them up slowly, and keep bounce/complaint rates low.

Why does my sub-account cap at 15,000 emails/day?

A sub-account without its own dedicated sending domain defaults to shared domain limits (15,000/day) even if the agency has a dedicated domain. To unlock 450,000/day, add a dedicated sending domain at the sub-account level.